Other Choice
Other Choice is a short-form host game in which a host interrupts performers mid-scene and prompts them to replace their most recent line or action with an alternative. Unlike New Choice, which accepts any substitution, Other Choice may impose a constraint on the replacement: the new choice must match a specified genre, emotional register, or style. The game tests verbal flexibility and the ability to generate alternatives under specific conditions.
Structure
Setup
Two or more performers begin a scene. A host stands outside the scene and monitors for moments to intervene.
Game
The scene proceeds normally. At any moment, the host calls "Other Choice" (or an equivalent prompt). The performer who most recently spoke or acted must immediately replace that line or action with a different one. The scene then continues from the new choice as if the original had never occurred.
In the constrained variant, the host specifies what kind of other choice is required: "Other Choice -- in the style of a soap opera," "Other Choice -- make it a question," "Other Choice -- whisper it." The performer must comply with the constraint while maintaining the scene's momentum.
The host may call for repeated substitutions on the same moment, forcing performers to generate multiple options before continuing.
Relationship to New Choice
Other Choice belongs to the same game family as New Choice. Both use the interrupt-and-replace mechanic and share the same core skill demand: rapid alternative generation without losing scene logic. Other Choice distinguishes itself by applying external constraints to the replacement rather than accepting any substitution.
How to Teach It
How to Explain It
"Play a scene. When I call other choice, whoever just spoke or moved must immediately make a different choice: a different word, a different action, a different emotion. The alternative is not worse than the first. It is different."
Objectives
Other Choice develops verbal flexibility and rapid alternative generation under constraints. It trains the specific skill of holding multiple possible choices simultaneously and selecting among them under time pressure. This skill transfers to scene work in which a performer realizes mid-sentence that their initial direction is not serving the scene and must pivot.
Using Constraints Pedagogically
The constrained version of the game is more valuable pedagogically than the unconstrained version. Specifying a genre, emotional register, or formal constraint forces performers to demonstrate whether they have internalized performance vocabulary beyond their default register. A performer who can produce five different "other choices" at five different emotional registers has a richer toolkit than one who can only generate alternatives at a single pitch.
For beginning students, start with simple binary constraints (louder/softer, faster/slower) before moving to genre constraints (soap opera, horror film, documentary).
How to Perform It
Generating Alternatives Quickly
The game demands immediate replacement without visible searching. Performers who pause conspicuously or who demonstrate that they cannot produce an alternative undermine the game's energy. The audience should see ease, even when the constraint is difficult.
The most effective strategy is to commit immediately to whatever comes first and trust that commitment will carry the replacement. A poorly conceived choice delivered confidently is more successful than a better choice delivered haltingly.
Working with Constraints
When the host specifies a genre or emotional register, performers must make the constraint visible rather than subtle. An "other choice in the style of a soap opera" should be unmistakably melodramatic; a whispered other choice should be genuinely whispered. Half-compliance with the constraint misses the comedic opportunity.
Partners who are not the target of the "Other Choice" call must also adjust: they receive a new line from their partner and must respond to it as if it were always what was said.
History
Other Choice belongs to the short-form interrupt game tradition that includes New Choice and related host-driven substitution games. No specific origin or first documented use has been identified in published improv sources. The game appears to have developed within short-form performance contexts where hosts look for ways to vary the New Choice mechanic by adding genre or style constraints.
Worth Reading
See all books →
Business Improv
Experiential Learning Exercises to Train Employees
Val Gee
The Improv Handbook
The Ultimate Guide to Improvising in Comedy, Theatre, and Beyond
Tom Salinsky; Deborah Frances-White
Improvisations in Creative Drama
A Program of Workshops
Betty Keller
The Upright Citizens Brigade Comedy Improvisation Manual
Matt Besser; Ian Roberts; Matt Walsh
The Improv Illusionist
Using Object Work, Environment, and Physicality in Performance
David Raitt
Improv for Actors
Dan Diggles
Related Games
New Choice
New Choice is a short-form game in which a caller interrupts performers mid-scene by shouting "New Choice," forcing the last speaker to immediately replace their most recent line or action with something entirely different. The caller may fire multiple calls in rapid succession, pushing performers through a cascade of alternatives under pressure. The game trains verbal agility, commitment to offers, and the capacity to abandon choices without hesitation.
Change
Change is a short-form game in which a caller says "change" at any point during a scene, forcing the last speaker to replace their most recent line with a new one. Repeated calls on the same line demand increasingly creative alternatives. The game trains verbal agility and the ability to generate multiple options for any moment.
Ding
Ding is a short-form game in which a host rings a bell or buzzer to signal a performer to replace their last line of dialogue with a new one. The host can ring repeatedly, demanding multiple replacements for the same moment, each new line erasing the previous one within the scene's reality. The game is one of the most widely performed short-form games in the world, popularized through its frequent appearance on Whose Line Is It Anyway? Ding rewards fast verbal invention, the ability to generate multiple alternatives under pressure, and the willingness to abandon a safe choice in favor of a riskier, funnier one.
Understudy
Understudy is a scene game in which performers replace one another mid-scene and must instantly continue as the character just vacated, adopting their voice, physicality, and emotional state. The replacing performer must observe closely while waiting and commit to a specific replication rather than a generic impression. The game trains character observation, physical specificity, and the ability to enter mid-scene without disrupting its reality.
Overload
Overload is a short-form game in which one or two performers must manage multiple simultaneous scenes or conversations, switching between them on the host's cue. As additional threads are added, the performers' struggle to track and maintain each one becomes the primary source of comedy. The game tests rapid context-switching, the ability to sustain distinct emotional registers simultaneously, and physical composure under mounting cognitive pressure.
Sing It
Sing It is a short-form game in which a host signals performers to interrupt their scene dialogue and immediately sing a song containing the word or phrase just spoken. The performer sings a relevant portion of the song, then returns to the scene. The game rewards broad musical knowledge, quick verbal association, and the willingness to commit to an unplanned song in public.
How to Reference This Page
The Improv Archive. (2026). Other Choice. Retrieved March 17, 2026, from https://improvarchive.org/games/other-choice
The Improv Archive. "Other Choice." The Improv Archive, 2026. https://improvarchive.org/games/other-choice.
The Improv Archive. "Other Choice." The Improv Archive, 2026, https://improvarchive.org/games/other-choice. Accessed March 17, 2026.
The Improv Archive is a systemically maintained repository. The archive itself acts as the corporate author.